Chuck and Buck

Is a preference to be affectionate toward persons of the same sex genetic or learned? Chuck&Buck, directed by Miguel Arteta, poses that question at the point where self-realization is likely to occur–the early teens. Although they were best friends as preteens and fooled around as early teens, when the film begins Buck O’Brien (played by Mike White) is twenty-seven years old. After taking care of his dying mother for five years, he wants to reconnect with Charles Sitter (played by Chris Weitz), a very attractive man who has become a successful media producer and has a beautiful fiancée. Unexpectedly, Buck drops by one day at Charles’s office, hoping again to hang out with the latter. Charles immediately senses that something is wrong about Buck’s overture and tries to put him off. Buck then proceeds to stalk Charles, his secretary, and even his fiancée. Buck also writes a play called “Frank and Hank,” which serves as a psychoautobiographical statement about his desire to have the same relationship with Chuck that they had earlier in life. While casting for the play, Buck prefers Sam (played by Paul Weitz), a macho guy who cannot act, to the chagrin of Beverly Franco (played by Lupe Ontiveros), the director of the play, as there is an unreciprocated sexual attraction on Buck’s side. Charles sees the play at the insistence of his fiancée, who realizes that Buck needs psychological help. Finally, Buck promises that he will stop bugging Charles if the latter will agree to spend one night together, and they end up in bed. Afterward, Buck moves into an apartment across from latent homosexual Sam; the two have become friends. When the film ends. Buck is attending the wedding of Charles and Sam. Doubtless, during the five years when Buck cared for his mother, the fantasy of a rekindling of a relationship with Chuck kept him going despite many hardships. The only way to end the fixation was to try out his fantasy. The story speaks volumes about the difficulties of finding gay partners. An early teen encounter might be understood later as experimentation for one, but another might take that relationship more seriously. Finally, the story hints that macho guys do not always acknowledge their homoerotic tendencies. Chuck&Buck may make little sense to straights but has a world of meaning to gays. MH

Scroll to Top